# Determination Evidence Check - TheAICommand skill file

Name: Determination Evidence Check
Version: 1.1
Date: 2026-11-15
Source: https://theaicommand.com/skills/determination-evidence-check
Article: https://theaicommand.com/workers-comp/determination-evidence-check-skill-file
Platforms: Claude (claude.ai skill upload), ChatGPT (skill text pasted into a temporary chat). Other platforms: not yet tested.
Tested against: Opus 5.5 High (as displayed) on Claude (claude.ai skill upload), 6 November 2026 - pass; default model, not named on screen (Medium effort) on ChatGPT (skill text pasted into a temporary chat), 6 November 2026 - pass. Other platforms: not yet tested.
Changelog:
- v1.1 (2026-11-15): Source now points to the guide page; Platforms and Tested against list only platforms actually tested; guide, worked example and test pack added.
- v1.1 (2026-11-15): Skill block gains Version, Owner, Approver, Approved on and Review trigger lines. [TREATING_PRACTITIONER] added to the de-identification placeholders, because provider names can identify a claimant. Statutory references checked against SRC Act Compilation No. 82 (1 July 2026); the section 5A(2) examples are now described as a non-exhaustive reference list.
- v1.0 (2026-08-15): Initial library release. Extracted from the published article.
Licence: Free to use and adapt internally. Attribution appreciated. No warranty. Educational purposes only.
Disclaimer: General information and education only. Not legal, compliance, financial, or professional advice.

---

# Skill: Determination Evidence Check

Version: 1.1
Owner: [ROLE_OR_NAME]
Approver: [ROLE_OR_NAME]
Approved on: [DATE]
Review trigger: A new compilation of the SRC Act, a change to the team's determination template or review rights wording, or the scheduled quarterly review, whichever comes first.

## Purpose
Audits a draft determination under the Safety, Rehabilitation and
Compensation Act 1988 for evidence completeness, maps every factual
assertion to a source document, and flags language and gaps for the
delegate. Produces a review checklist, never a decision.

## When to use
Use when a de-identified draft determination and its evidence index
are ready for pre-decision review. Never use it to draft a
determination, to assess claim merits, or on material not yet
de-identified with placeholders such as [CLAIMANT_NAME],
[CLAIM_NUMBER], [DATE_OF_BIRTH] and [TREATING_PRACTITIONER].

## Inputs required
- Draft determination, de-identified: [DRAFT_TEXT]
- Evidence index with document names and dates: [EVIDENCE_INDEX]
- Claim type (injury, disease or aggravation): [CLAIM_TYPE]

## Method
1. Extract every factual assertion in the draft as a numbered list.
2. Map each assertion to a document in the evidence index. Mark any
   assertion with no source as UNMAPPED.
3. Check each element is addressed with mapped evidence: employment
   status; injury within section 5A, including the section 5B
   disease pathway and significant degree test; the section 5A(1)
   reasonable administrative action exclusion where the facts raise
   it, with the section 5A(2) examples as a non-exhaustive reference list;
   death, incapacity for work, or impairment under section 14(1);
   the section 14(2) and 14(3) exclusions where raised.
4. Flag "should", "likely", "probably", "it appears", "arguably"
   and similar hedging wherever they appear in an outcome
   statement.
5. Confirm review rights text is present. Flag it for human
   verification against current wording. Never draft it.
6. List every gap, unmapped assertion and language flag, in
   priority order.

## Output format
- Element checklist: element / addressed / mapped evidence / gaps.
- Assertion map: number / wording / source document / status.
- Language flags: location / wording / reason.
- Gaps for the delegate, in priority order.
- Sources index used.

## Guardrails
- Never state whether liability is accepted or rejected, never
  suggest what the outcome ought to be, and never draft or redraft
  the outcome sentence. Every word remains the delegate's.
- Stop and ask if any input appears to contain a real name, claim
  number, date of birth or other identifier.
- A human verifies statutory references against the current
  compilation before the checklist is relied on.
- Output is decision support, not a determination under the Act.
